91原创

Everyone who came got a consultation with a conservator who specialized in the material of the object they brought. Community members heard about potential options for treatment, what sort of supplies could be helpful, what the next steps could be.

These consultations required careful consideration of personal safety. So much toxic material was left behind by the fires 鈥� in the air, on objects, in the ground and in the waterways 鈥� that handling and working with items exposed to these hazards could be dangerous indeed.

Personal protective equipment (PPE) 鈥� masks, Tyvek aprons and sleeves, gloves 鈥� was mandatory for the conservators, who were also urged to bring special vacuums that could be used to clean objects without damaging them.

鈥淚t was a BYOV event 鈥� bring your own vacuum,鈥� Schindler said. 鈥淲e used HEPA filter vacuums. If the object was safe and stable enough, the conservators would do the vacuuming for you and send you home with a cleaner piece while demonstrating how to use the vacuums and sponges 鈥� and now you can do the work.鈥�

Do-it-yourself cleaning kits, including PPE, were provided free of charge by the Los Angeles Department of Art and Culture, too.

For such a time as this

Students never really know where their studies will take them, what their training might prepare them to do.

But in this case, these two W91原创PAC graduates knew they were ready and willing to invest their expertise to address the needs of their community.

鈥淥ur graduate students are well-prepared with knowledge, skills, critical thinking, communication skills and leadership skills to help in these situations,鈥� said Debra Hess Norris, director of W91原创PAC, Unidel Henry Francis DuPont Chair and professor of photograph conservation at 91原创. 鈥淎nd to be there 鈥� it鈥檚 not just the hands-on work. It鈥檚 also the emotional work. They have the skills and knowledge and capacity to help, and they also have the need and obligation to help. And they do so brilliantly. I鈥檓 so grateful they鈥檙e able to get involved and we continue to incorporate this kind of education and training in our core curriculum.鈥�

Brockman鈥檚 art conservation journey started briefly with objects, before moving into paper conservation during pre-graduate program internships.

鈥淭here鈥檚 so much paper in the world,鈥� she said. 鈥淚t鈥檚 a very widespread democratic-type medium. Everybody has paper 鈥� whether it鈥檚 a fine art project, ancient papyrus, an old master print or drawing, a movie star鈥檚 signature that you got on a cocktail napkin or family archives.鈥�

Paper conservation is deceptively difficult, Brockman said.

鈥淲e do either dry treatment or wet treatment 鈥� water-based treatments. There鈥檚 no real room for error,鈥� she said. 鈥淚t can be super, super delicate. I like the challenge that comes along with that.鈥�

Brockman grew up in the Los Angeles area and returned there after graduating from the W91原创PAC program in 2019.

After moving back to Los Angeles, Brockman worked at the Los Angeles County Museum of Art. She now works in private practice with L.A. Art Conservation, a firm specializing in paper conservation started by former LACMA colleague Erin Jue.

Schindler, who graduated from the W91原创PAC program in 2022, said 91原创 was supportive of a critical goal to work with items related to Judaica and Jewish culture.

鈥淧art of my first year of grad school was figuring out what that meant,鈥� Schindler said. 鈥淲hat does the community need? What should I study in order to best support them? I landed on a newer field 鈥� preventive conservation. 91原创 was the only grad program that offers that major.鈥�

Schindler was the fourth to graduate with that degree.

鈥淚 describe it as being a primary care physician as opposed to being a heart surgeon,鈥� Schindler said. 鈥淲e look at things in a zoomed out way. We look at the wellness of the collection, wellness care, capital 鈥楽鈥� Sustainable and little 鈥榮鈥� sustainable. We want to make smart choices that have a smaller carbon footprint, and we want to give a realistic path forward, within the available resources.

鈥淚 carved out a Jewish/Judaica subfield and it has been such a blessing. I knew I wanted to support small collections that would never be able to support a conservator full time.鈥�

Now, as a 鈥渟olopreneur鈥� and founder of , Judaica and Jewish material culture is the focus. There is secular work, too, but the Jewish work carries special weight.

Schindler moved to L.A. from Wilmington, Delaware, about a year ago, found a robust conservation community and some great neighbors.

Suddenly, in January, everything changed as some of the most destructive wildfires in California history swept through their region on a 24-day rampage.

Living through the trauma

Neither Brockman nor Schindler lost their homes in those fires. But evacuation orders soon came for Schindler鈥檚 Runyon Canyon community.

They had 10 minutes to pack up. Pro tip: Decide before an emergency which three nostalgic items you鈥檙e going to take with you. Schindler and a neighbor had recently had exactly that conversation.

鈥淭he blanket my grandmother knitted for me 鈥� that was priority No. 1,鈥� Schindler said. Then there were journals full of art and doodles and drawings and collages, along with a small container of 鈥渢chotchkes鈥� 鈥� those little household trinkets that often become heirlooms.聽

Then came a flood of other questions.

鈥淲here are we going to go? What do we do? We couldn鈥檛 hear each other over the sirens and the flames were four blocks away. I hopped in my neighbor鈥檚 car and we drove to her parents鈥� house and crashed there a few days.鈥�

That L.A. community vibe was powerful, Schindler said.

鈥淚t was 鈥楥ome share my childhood bed at my parents鈥� house and we鈥檒l figure it out together. Jump in our car if you need to.鈥� People were checking in left and right. It鈥檚 an Angeleno 鈥榳e are in it together鈥� attitude.鈥�

It was a jarring stretch of time 鈥� an experience that provided special empathy for those who had so many questions about objects they had saved or salvaged.

鈥淚n some ways, it helps. I can understand what people are going through because I went through it. Those 10 minutes 鈥� that rush of adrenaline was crazy and it was really scary. I can connect with people in that human way.鈥�

Stress and anxiety were common throughout the region.

鈥淲e have dealt with wildfires before and crazy El Ninos,鈥� Brockman said. 鈥淏ut this was the biggest and closest incident. I鈥檝e lived here my whole life and this is the worst I鈥檝e ever experienced. The weather patterns over the last 30 years are very different now than when I was a kid.鈥�

One way forward was to help. It was a much different kind of help than typical conservation work.

鈥淥rdinarily, it鈥檚 people who just want to conserve one object or a few objects,鈥� Brockman said. 鈥淢aybe they had a small leak in their house. Or they found this item in an antique market. Now it鈥檚 鈥� 鈥楥an you please help all of us because entire neighborhoods have burned down?鈥� We鈥檙e not dealing with isolated art works. We鈥檙e dealing with a whole house of artworks and cherished belongings.鈥�

An effective approach to that requires good connections, planning, communication and some MacGyver-like creativity.

鈥淏eing of service feels really good,鈥� Schindler said. 鈥淚n that first week after the fire, as things were kind of easing, the focus shifted to air quality. I was so anxious, I wasn鈥檛 sleeping. So I pulled together an annotated bibliography.鈥�

Because, of course. Wouldn鈥檛 an annotated bibliography be on your to-do list?

鈥淚鈥檓 such a W91原创PAC-rat,鈥� Schindler said. 鈥淚 have resources and I know they鈥檙e reliable. I know how to share them. I can鈥檛 help everyone in the city, but this was a helpful way to channel my nervous energy into this document, attempting to get information into the hands of folks who needed it.鈥�

It was three or four pages鈥� worth of credible, accurate information, connections, links to tutorials 鈥� a roadmap to a path forward.

鈥淲e want to help people understand that a lot of basic things they can do themselves,鈥� Brockman said. 鈥淎nd we want to offer as much support as we can.鈥�

Support for the helpers, help for the objects

It wasn鈥檛 long before they heard from Debra Hess Norris, director of the W91原创PAC Program.

鈥淪he asked 鈥楬ow can 91原创 help? What can we do to support you?鈥欌�� Schindler said. 鈥淭hey were able to pull some funds together to send our way. With all of this donated time, that 91原创 support allows us to breathe a little easier.鈥�

That is a powerful aspect of the 91原创 program, Brockman said.
鈥淚 feel like I鈥檝e leaned a lot on the support network of the instructors I had in grad school. This is why this program is so great 鈥� not just the program, but the support network afterwards.鈥�

Within weeks of the fires, like-minded conservators converged 鈥� including others with 91原创 connections, such as Ellen Moody, who earned her master鈥檚 in objects and preventive conservation at W91原创PAC, and Yulimar Luna Col贸n, who earned her bachelor鈥檚 in art conservation and art history at 91原创 鈥� and Art Recovery L.A. was born.

Brockman built ARLA鈥檚 website and produced short instructional videos on how to use PPE and basic remediation treatments. The group has hosted 鈥淚nstagram Live鈥� events and a 鈥淒on鈥檛 Toss It鈥� campaign was launched to encourage people to hold on to recovered items in case they could be salvaged.

Soon the first public conservation clinic was on the calendar. And then scores of people were arriving with stuff they had pulled from many different situations.

Not much paper 鈥� if any 鈥� would survive a fire that burns a structure to the ground. Ceramics and metal objects have a better chance.

鈥淏ut there are things that are in close proximity to a fire but are not burned,鈥� Brockman said. 鈥淪moke and ash and soot are really bad for everything 鈥� for our health and for objects. Things in frames 鈥� photos, prints, drawings 鈥� have a little layer of protection around them. But if they鈥檙e in close proximity to fire, I鈥檝e seen acrylic or Plexiglas framing that warps and you鈥檙e worried about the artwork inside. If it鈥檚 not framed, it鈥檚 a bigger issue.鈥�

Salvaged items were evaluated, vacuums sucked up ash and soot, tears were shed.

One woman brought in a set of bedroom curtains. She had lung problems and wasn鈥檛 sure she should keep them.

鈥淲e鈥檙e not industrial hygienists, but we talked through options,鈥� Schindler said.

The first clinic drew more than 110 objects 鈥� baskets, ceramics, mugs, jewelry, a menorah, some ritual objects, books, photos, stuffed animals, a few wall hangings.

鈥淭he bigger conversation now is 鈥� how are these objects a prompt for storytelling and healing?鈥� Schindler said. 鈥淕etting to safety is first, of course 鈥� your health is a priority. But why do these objects matter to people? While we are here to talk about storage and handling and treatment, what we really want to hear is what does this object mean to you? What is the story you are rescuing from this rubble?鈥�

The meaning of a mural

Another casualty of these vicious fires was the Pasadena Jewish Temple and Center. The conservative synagogue, more than 100 years old, was burned to the ground in the Eaton Canyon fire.

The Torah scrolls were saved, Schindler said, but little else survived. Only one wall was still standing 鈥� but it was especially astonishing. The fa莽ade of the wall had burned away, revealing a 25-foot-high mural no one knew was there.

鈥淚t鈥檚 very faint,鈥� Schindler said. 鈥淚t has imagery of people playing instruments, with donkeys, animals, trees all around. It鈥檚 hard to see and figure out what is going on.鈥�

Schindler鈥檚 partner, who is in rabbinical school at Hebrew Union College, connected Schindler with the board of the synagogue and Schindler called Kiernan Graves of Site & Studio Conservation, a conservator who specializes in wall paintings.

A couple weeks after the fire, they learned the first rain was in the forecast, so they went to the site to protect the mural by putting Tyvek sheeting over it. They were fighting the clock and the process was more complicated than they anticipated.

鈥淭hat was a really hard day,鈥� Schindler said. 鈥淚t was physically and emotionally exhausting to be literally walking through rubble and kicking up soot. The playground was melted. It was devastating. I was in full hazmat with a face respirator and goggles, layers of gloves. It drove home to me the importance of personal protective equipment (PPE).鈥�

Later, they raised funds to rent a cherry picker 鈥� also known as a boom lift 鈥� so they could reach the upper parts of the mural, secure the Tyvek tent and do much closer inspection. They planned to do more research on the history of the site and the origin of that mural.

But, alas, the site had to be cleared of hazardous materials and the wall was demolished by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers as part of that remedial process.

Though their skills can often make museum pieces out of what seems like a lost cause, conservators must work within the constraints of finances, time and the owner鈥檚 priorities. The synagogue had identified health, safety and rebuilding as its priorities for the site, and the wall鈥檚 demolition made sense within that context, Schindler said.

鈥淲e were able to salvage some pieces and we have high-quality images, but the mural is no longer intact,鈥� Schindler said. 鈥淲e will continue our research and figure out what next steps can be done with the salvaged pieces.鈥�

Preparing for future crises

All of these experiences and new connections provide a strong foundation for what will surely be part of the future 鈥� more crises.

鈥淭he unfortunate truth is this: climate change,鈥� Schindler said. 鈥淭his will be one of many future disasters. There will be floods, winds, mudslides. Being an established group will allow us to be a resource for people as we go forward.鈥�

It鈥檚 essential for everyone to prepare for the future, to consider plans and ask the hard questions ahead of time.

鈥淓veryone in L.A. is now familiar with a 鈥榞o bag,鈥欌�� Schindler said. 鈥淭hey know where their passport is, their prescriptions and bottles of water. But what things are you going to salvage? Do you have insurance? What does your policy cover? Do storage containers matter?鈥�

The W91原创PAC program was an excellent proving ground not only for techniques of conservation, but also in 鈥渟oft skills,鈥� Schindler said, pointing to the DELPHI (Delaware Public Humanities Institute) program as an example.

鈥淲hen I attended, it was a two-week program,鈥� Schindler said. 鈥淚t was during the COVID pandemic, so it was all on Zoom. We came up with personal mission statements, worked on our 鈥榚levator pitches鈥� and did a little media training. All of that has been helpful to me in this moment and in my career in general.鈥�